Replacing Your Bathtub with a Walk-In Shower: Costs, Benefits, and What to Expect
If you’re thinking about replacing your bathtub with a walk-in shower, you’re probably wondering if it’s the right move for your home. This is a big decision, and there are several factors to consider—from practical functionality to future resale value. Let’s explore this question in depth so you can feel confident about your choice.
In this article, we’ll cover everything you need to know about replacing a bathtub with a walk-in shower, including:
Whether it’s okay to replace a tub with a shower
How this change impacts resale value
What to do if the tub you’re replacing is the only one in the house
Factors affecting the cost of replacing a bathtub with a walk-in shower
How long the project takes
Pitfalls to avoid
And much more!
By the end, you’ll have all the details you need to decide if this project is right for your home.
What work is involved in replacing a bathtub with a walk-in shower?
Let’s start with the basics. What does this project entail? Just a bit of demo and plumbing work, right? Not exactly.
Replacing a bathtub with a walk-in shower involves more than you might expect. Here’s a quick overview of the work:
Demolition: Removing the existing bathtub, surround, and fixtures.
Framing: Installing blocking for new fixtures and shower walls.
Plumbing: Updating or replacing plumbing lines and the drain.
Shower Installation: Installing a prefabricated shower base and walls, or waterproofing and tiling.
Drywall Patching: Repairing the walls cut back during demolition.
Floor Patching/Replacement: Adjusting or replacing flooring around the new shower.
Fixture Installation: Adding faucets, showerheads, and accessories.
Glass Enclosure: Installing a door or panel for a polished finish.
Finishing Touches: Painting, sealing, and adding design elements.
Each step requires careful planning and skilled execution to ensure the project is completed properly. This process involves coordination between several different professionals and trades to ensure every detail meets the highest standards.
Can I replace my bathtub with a walk-in shower?
A tub to shower conversion is a popular renovation project. However, it’s important to assess whether this change makes sense for your home. In most cases, the project is feasible, but a couple of factors can make it less ideal:
Inadequate Plumbing: Depending on local codes, your contractor may need to upgrade the plumbing for the new shower, which can add complexity and cost.
Resale Value Impact: Removing a bathtub, especially in single-bathroom homes, can deter potential buyers who value having at least one tub.
Let’s dive into these issues, to see if this project will make sense for your home.
How do I know if my plumbing system is adequate for a shower conversion?
Showers generally require a 2-inch drain to prevent water from pooling, whereas most bathtubs use a 1½-inch drain. In many cases, your existing drain will work as-is, but some local jurisdictions may require an upgrade to meet shower drainage standards.
The complexity of plumbing modifications often depends on the location of your bathroom. For example:
Connecting or upgrading plumbing in an unfinished basement is typically straightforward.
Installing a shower on a second floor often involves removing drywall or opening the subfloor to gain access to the pipes.
Converting a basement bathroom could even require jackhammering concrete to adjust the plumbing- a very messy and time-consuming process.
While these adjustments can add time and cost, they’re essential for ensuring proper drainage and preventing future issues.
The good news? Most of the time, plumbing modifications are manageable and relatively affordable. For more complex projects, a professional plumbing contractor can assess your system and let you know what’s needed before the project begins.
Will replacing a bathtub with a shower affect my home’s resale value?
Replacing a bathtub with a walk-in shower can be a practical and stylish upgrade, but its impact on resale value depends on several factors:
Multiple-Bathroom Homes: If your home has more than one bathroom, replacing a tub with a shower is unlikely to hurt resale value. Buyers will still have access to at least one bathtub.
Single-Bathroom Homes: In single-bathroom homes, removing the only bathtub can make your home less appealing to families with young children or buyers who enjoy soaking in a tub. If this applies to you, consider alternatives like a tub-shower combo or reserving space for a freestanding tub elsewhere.
High-End Homes: Luxury buyers often expect both a walk-in shower and a separate soaking tub. If you’re remodeling a high-end property, maintaining or adding a bathtub might be wise.
If you’re uncertain about how this project might affect your home’s value, consult a local real estate agent or appraiser. They can provide insights specific to your market and help you make an informed decision.
What should I do if this is the only bathtub in my home?
When the bathtub you’re replacing is the only one in your home, it’s essential to weigh your options carefully. Here are a few strategies to consider:
Add a Bathtub Elsewhere: If you have the space and budget, installing a bathtub in another bathroom can maintain balance.
Opt for a Hybrid Solution: A tub-shower combination offers flexibility for both bathing and showering.
Prioritize Your Needs: If you plan to stay in your home long-term and rarely use the tub, prioritize your preferences and lifestyle.
Consult a Realtor: If you plan on selling at some point, a local real estate expert can provide guidance on how this change might impact your home’s appeal to future buyers.
Ultimately, the decision should align with your personal needs and long-term goals for your home.
How much does it cost to replace a bathtub with a walk-in shower?
In Portsmouth, NH, and the surrounding Seacoast area, the cost of a tub to shower conversion typically ranges from $12,000 to $30,000 or more. The final price depends on the materials, features, and complexity of the project. Here’s a closer look:
Basic Tub Conversion ($12,000–$18,000): This option covers a straightforward swap using standard materials, such as a prefabricated shower unit. It includes demolition, plumbing adjustments, and installation.
Mid-Range Upgrade ($18,000–$25,000): For this price range, you can expect upgraded materials like solid surface shower walls, porcelain tile, or frameless glass enclosures that add style and durability.
Luxury Remodel ($30,000+): At this level, you’re investing in a custom shower design with premium finishes, integrated seating, multiple showerheads, and other high-end features that create a spa-like experience.
These budgets include both labor and materials, with labor typically accounting for 70–80% of the total cost. To get a more precise estimate for your unique project, reach out to a reputable contractor for a comprehensive quote.
What factors affect the cost of a tub to shower conversion?
Several variables influence the cost of these types of projects, including:
Material Choices: Premium materials like custom tile or frameless glass increase costs.
Plumbing Adjustments: Upgrading drains or plumbing lines will add expense.
Floor & Wall Adjustments: Extensive structural modifications can drive up costs, especially if hidden issues like water damage are discovered.
Size & Design: Larger showers or custom designs with features like built-in seating or multiple showerheads require more materials and labor.
Labor Costs: The contractor’s expertise and the complexity of the work significantly impact pricing.
Working with an experienced design-build contractor or interior designer can ensure your budget is spent wisely—focusing on the features that enhance your daily life while avoiding unnecessary expenses
How long does it take to complete a tub to shower conversion?
The timeline for replacing a bathtub with a walk-in shower typically ranges from two to three weeks. Here’s what you can typically expect:
Demolition: 1–2 days to remove the old bathtub and prepare the space.
Plumbing Adjustments: 1–3 days to upgrade or reconfigure plumbing.
Shower Installation: 1–5 days for the base, walls, and fixtures.
Finishing Touches: 1–3 days for sealing, painting, and final adjustments.
Inspection & Cleanup: 1–2 days to ensure everything is up to code and tidy.
Basic projects with prefabricated units may take as little as 1 week, while custom tile installations can take 2-3 weeks, or more. A clear project schedule provided by your contractor can help set expectations for your specific project.
Are there any pitfalls I should avoid when replacing a bathtub with a shower?
While this project might seem straightforward, there are some common mistakes to avoid:
Underestimating the Scope: Many homeowners assume replacing a bathtub with a shower is a simple plumbing job, only to realize too late that the plumber’s quote didn’t include framing, flooring, drywall, or painting.
Ignoring Drainage: Proper drainage is often overlooked, but it’s essential for a functional and code-compliant shower. Many older bathtubs have smaller drains, which may not handle the higher water flow from a walk-in shower, especially if you’re adding features like multiple showerheads. Failing to upgrade the drain can lead to slow draining, clogs, or even flooding.
Skipping Waterproofing: Waterproofing isn’t just about installing tile; it’s about creating a barrier that protects your home from water damage. Without a waterproof membrane under the tile or around the shower walls, water can seep into the surrounding structure, leading to mold, mildew, and rot. These issues can be expensive and disruptive to repair, so investing in proper waterproofing upfront is a must.
Choosing Cheap Materials: While budget-friendly materials might seem appealing, they often come with hidden costs. For example, inexpensive shower pans or tiles may crack, discolor, or degrade over time, requiring replacement sooner than expected. Higher-quality materials not only last longer but also elevate the overall aesthetic and value of your home.
Hiring Inexperienced Contractors: The skill and expertise of your contractor can make or break your project. Inexperienced contractors might cut corners or overlook crucial details, such as waterproofing, leveling the shower floor, or aligning the shower doors correctly. This can lead to costly repairs down the line. Partnering with a seasoned professional ensures the job is done right the first time.
By addressing these common pitfalls with care and working with an experienced contractor, you can avoid surprises and enjoy a seamless transition from bathtub to shower.
What kind of contractor do I need for a tub to shower conversion?
Replacing a bathtub with a shower usually involves more than just hiring a plumber. The type of contractor(s) you’ll need depends on how you approach the project. Let’s break it down:
Plumber + DIY: If you’re comfortable with hands-on work, you can hire a plumber for key tasks like setting the shower pan and installing the drain, then handle the rest yourself. While this is the most budget-friendly option, it demands significant time, effort, and skill—and mistakes can be costly.
Multiple Trade Contractors: You can hire individual trades for each part of the project, such as plumbers, carpenters, drywallers, and painters. While this approach gives you control, it’s time-consuming and often stressful to coordinate schedules and ensure everyone is on the same page.
General Contractor: A general contractor oversees every aspect of the project, from plumbing and framing to finishing touches like painting. This option offers the most seamless and professional experience, saving you the hassle of managing multiple contractors while ensuring the work is done right.
At Rothrock Kitchen & Bath, we specialize in comprehensive bathroom remodels, handling every detail with expertise and care so you can focus on enjoying the results, not managing the process.
Final thoughts
Replacing a bathtub with a walk-in shower is a practical, stylish upgrade that can enhance your home’s functionality and value. By working with a skilled contractor, you’ll navigate plumbing codes, design choices, and installation challenges with confidence.
At Rothrock Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, we specialize in creating beautiful, functional bathrooms tailored to your lifestyle. If you’re ready to replace your bathtub with a walk-in shower in Portsmouth, NH, contact us today to schedule a consultation. Let’s bring your dream bathroom to life!
